| | Dineshvs 
 |  |  |  | Saturday, June 12, 2004 - 3:17 pm: |       |  
 | 
 ka kuNaasa za}kÊ pNa maI baáyaaca idvasaanaI qao AalaÜya. ³ervaI dusarIkDo saMcaartÜ´Ê
 kahI svar laavatanaa tÜMD vaoDovaakDo kravao laagato ho Kro AahoÊ pNa baalagaMQava- AaiNa jayamaalaa iXalaodar
yaanaa tsao kravao laagat nasao AaiNa naahI. %yaanaa gaatanaa jyaanaI paihlaoya %yaanaa na@kIca ho pTola.
 maI maagao maayabaÜilavar talaacaa t>a idlaa hÜta. kuzlaohI jaunao gaaNao laagalao AaiNa tÜ t>a
DÜL\yaasamaÜr AaNalaa tr tala na@kIca AÜLKta yaotÜ.
 
 
 | 
| BaavanaaÊ maagacyaa vaYaI-Ê laÜkrMga ³rivavaar - laÜksa<aa´ maQyao tU var mhTlao AahosaÊ AgadI tXaI maaihtI Acyaut gaÜDbaÜlao AaiNa saulaBaa ipXavaIkr
dr AazvaD\yaalaa Ëmaanao ilahayacao. %yaat AaQaI %yaa ragaacao saUrÊ %yaacaa ]gama kuzo ina ksaa JaalaaÊ
%yaa ragaaivaYayaIcao ikssaoÊ samajautIÊ gaOrsamajautI vagaOro ho saaMgaayacao.
 AaiNa maga laoKacyaa ]<araQaa-tÊ %yaa ragaaXaI inagaiDt AsalaolaI ihMdI ica~pT gaItoÊ naaT\yagaItoÊ
marazI ica~pT gaItoÊ Aar%yaa yaaMcaa Qaavata AaZavaa Gaotlaolaa Asaayacaa. AitXaya Cana maaihtI ilaihlaI
%yaaMnaI vaYa-Bar...
 
 maa^DroTrÊ var  Girishmusic  yaaMcyaa pÜsT naMtr BarpUr Aitir> jaagaa Aaho. toqao  image  Aaho kayaÆ
 
 imailaMdaÊ
   ...³Kalacyaa pÜsTsaazI ´ 
 
 | 
| | Milindaa 
 |  |  |  | Tuesday, June 22, 2004 - 11:19 am: |       |  
 | 
 kuzo Aaho jaagaa Æ
   
 
 | 
| | Aaftaab 
 |  |  |  | Monday, June 28, 2004 - 9:31 am: |       |  
 | 
 Any hindusthani classical enthusiasts in/nearby Boston? Any teachers around there?
 
 
 | 
| | Bgovekar 
 |  |  |  | Friday, July 02, 2004 - 7:37 am: |       |  
 | 
 GD Ê Krca Cana va ]pyau> maaihtI Aaho tI. %yaa  link  tu [qao donaa mhNajao Kup jaNaaMnaa %yaacaa fayada hÜla.
 
 
 | 
| raag maarva var adharit gani detoy:
 1. Saanz bhayi ghar aaja..
 2. Dolyaat saanjveli aanu nakos paani...
 3. Swaragangechya kathavarati vachan dile tu  mala...
 4. khinna yaa vaata, duur palanaaryaa...
 5. shabda - shabda japun vech bakulichya fula pari...
 anakhi kunala mahit ahet ka?
 
 
 | 
| | Aaftaab 
 |  |  |  | Monday, July 19, 2004 - 7:40 pm: |       |  
 | 
 classical music related discussions nehmi 'ragavar adharit gaaNi' ithech jaun ka thambtaat? TyasaaThi separate BB aahe na.
 Mazhya mate ithe vegavegalya raagaanche details, gayan shaili, concert updates vagaire discuss vhayala hava..
 What say mandaLi?
 
 
 | 
| | Jashwini 
 |  |  |  | Tuesday, July 20, 2004 - 6:43 am: |       |  
 | 
 34ÂjaÜhar maayabaap jaÜhar34Â ho naa%yagaIt kuqalyaa ragaatIla Aaho AaiNa kuqalyaa naTkatIla AahoÆ
 
 
 
 | 
| | Asami 
 |  |  |  | Tuesday, July 20, 2004 - 8:04 pm: |       |  
 | 
 Natak : Sangeet Kanhopatra
 
 
 | 
| | Abhijit 
 |  |  |  | Tuesday, July 20, 2004 - 10:32 pm: |       |  
 | 
 AaiNa raga BaOrvaI .. ..
 
 
 | 
| | Jashwini 
 |  |  |  | Wednesday, July 21, 2004 - 5:23 am: |       |  
 | 
 thx Abhijit aani Asami
   yaa gaanyaacao baÜla   internet \dev( vara miLateela kaa?}
 
 
 | 
| | Chinmay 
 |  |  |  | Wednesday, July 21, 2004 - 5:53 am: |       |  
 | 
 nakskarÊ
 Xaas~Iya saMgaIta varcaI tumacaI cacaa- Cana vaaTlaI. kÜNaalaa GaraNaa ivaXayaI maaihtI Aaho kaÆ mhNajaoÊ
 1. gaaNyaat iktI GaraNao AahotÆ malaa dÜnaca maahIt AahotÊ ikraNaa AaiNa maovaatI
 2. Amauk klaakar eka   perticular GaraNyaacaa Aaho ho %yaacaa  style vaÉna samajat kaÆ
 
 
 
 | 
| | Jashwini 
 |  |  |  | Thursday, July 22, 2004 - 6:11 am: |       |  
 | 
 maJyaa maaihtI p`maaNao eKada gaayak jyaa GaraNyaa kDUna sangaItacao iXa@XaNa GaotÜ %yaa GaraNyaaica %yaaica
  style AapÜAap  develop hÜto. m*Najao tumhI jyaa GarNyaa%lyaa gaayakakDo iXakta %yaa GarNyaatlao gayak banat.  But I think it wont be so easy. U need to be at some good level to be known as an official singar for any gharana.
 
 
 | 
| | Gs1 
 |  |  |  | Friday, July 23, 2004 - 12:38 pm: |       |  
 | 
 gauÉvaar id. 29 rÜjaI maaJaI baayakÜ Écaacaa Xaas~Iya gaayanaacaa kya-Ëma Aaho saMQyaakaLI 6.30 laaÊ esa
ema jaÜXaI saBaagaRhÊ p~kar BavanaaXaojaarI.
 Écaa Da^ p`Baa A~o yaaMcaI iXaYyaa Aaho. puNyaatlyaa sava- tanasaona va kanasaona maayabaÜilakraMnaa ho
Kasa inamaM~Na
 Ìpyaa malaa maola pazvauna yaoNaar Asalyaacao kLvaavaoÊ mhNajao maI maaJaa Toila naMbar do]na zovaona
saMpka-saazI.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 | 
| | Dineshvs 
 |  |  |  | Friday, July 23, 2004 - 3:40 pm: |       |  
 | 
 maI nasalaÜ trI maaJao kana AaiNa mana %yaa maOÔIlaIt na@kI Asaola.
 
 AilakDoca GaraNao yaa ivaYayaavar saMgaIt sairta maQao Cana maailaka JaalaI. %yaatlao kaihsao kNa.
 
 Aaga`aÊ jayapurÊ gvaalhor ih kaih GaraNaI.
 p`%yaok GaraNyaacao ek gaanapQatI Asato. %yaatlao iXaYya %yaa prMprot tyaar hÜtat. pNa kaih p`itBaavaMt
ho sava- pcavauna AaplaI svatÁcao GaraNao inamaa-Na krtat. kumaar gaMQava- ho zLk ]dahrNa. pMDIt vasaMtrava
doXapaMDo pNaÊ Aamacao GaraNao Aamacyaapasauna sau$ hÜto Asao mhNat Asat.
 
 Aata Da^. p`aBaa A~o yaa ikraNaa GaraNyaacyaaÊ pNa %yaaMcao gaaNao iBamasaonajaIMpoxaa iktI vaogaLo Aaho
to jaaNataca. %yaaMcaI sargama gaayacaI irt tr Kasa eokNyaasaarKI. ikXaÜrI AmaÜNakranaI pNa jayapur A~ÝlaI
GaraNyaacaI gaayakI kQaIca maagao saÜDlaI.
 
 kaih GaraNyaacaI svatacaI pwt Asato Asao var ilaihlao Aaho %yaacao ]dahrNa mhNajao gvaalhor GaraNyaacaI
AaËmak gaayakI. tI eokNyaasaazI maailanaI rajaurkr eokavyaat.
 
 Aaplao ramaBaa] marazo tr tIna tIna GaraNyaaMcaI gaayakI gaat Asat.
 
 
 | 
| chala. atta kuthe changli 'gharanedaar' charcha suru zali. tya anushangane anakhi kahi maahitee deto ahe.
 gharani mukhya chaar:
 gwalher(gwaliar), agra, jaipur ani kirana.
 pt. v.h.deshpande ya tajdnyanni swar ani laya pradhaan gharanyanche vargikaran kele ahe. gwalior mhanje baalbodh gayaki, agra mhanje akramak-laya pradhan gayaki, jaipur mhanje taan yukta pan swar - laya donhinchaa samanway saadhnari gayaki.
 mag itar anek gharani jase rampur-sahaswan, mewati, banaras vagaire tyanchya paddhati pramane swarapradhaan kinva layapradhan thartaat.
 Kumar Gandharva he maze fevourate gayak. mazya mate tyanchya itka samjun gaanara gayak aaj paryanta kuni zala nasava. Te swatahala gwalior gayak manayche. karan tyaach paramparetoon te ale hote. parampara cha aadar kiti karava ani nava nirmitee chi survat kuthun hote he tyanna spashtapane kalalela hota.
 
 
 | 
| maUL GaraNaI f> 3 Asao isaw\haqa- basaUcyaa eka kaya-Ëmaat eoklao hÜto ... gvaalhorÊ Aaga`aÊ itsaro
jayapUr ikMvaa ikraNaa
 
 GaraNyaaMcaI ]%p<aI tanasaona pasaUna JaalaI Asao mhNatat.
 
 yaabaabatIMt kuNaI AaNaKI maaihtI do[la ka Æ
 
 
 | 
| | Dineshvs 
 |  |  |  | Wednesday, July 28, 2004 - 3:10 pm: |       |  
 | 
 naahI GaraNaI jaast Aahot. bahutok GaraNyaacaa mauL gaayak AsatÜca. tanasaonacao GaraNao Asao maaJyaa
trI eokIvaat naahI.
 %yaanao rcalaolao imayaa ik tÜDIÊ imayaa kI malharÊ imayaa kI saarMga va %yaacyaa maulaanao rcalaolaa
ibalaasaKanaI tÜDI ho raga maa~ p`caarat Aahot.
 
 
 | 
| | Chinmay 
 |  |  |  | Friday, July 30, 2004 - 4:29 am: |       |  
 | 
 GarNyaaMvar ek caaMgalaI saa[T Aaho. Cana maaihtI idlaI Aaho.
 
 http://makar-records.com/siteus/framegenre.html
 
 
 
 
 | 
| | Shriramb 
 |  |  |  | Friday, July 30, 2004 - 5:19 am: |       |  
 | 
 See this also: http://itcsra.org
 
 
 | 
| ikrvaaNaI ivaYayaI kÜNaI maaihtI do] XakolaÆ
 
 
 | 
| | Dineshvs 
 |  |  |  | Friday, July 30, 2004 - 3:15 pm: |       |  
 | 
 ikrvaaNaI raga
 
 AarÜh saa ro ga ma p Qa ina saaM
 AvarÜh saaM ina Qa p ma ga ro saa
 
 vaadI ro saMvaadI p
 
 vaL ra~Icaa itsar p`hr
 
 gaaNaI yaad na jaayao baIto idnaÜMkI
 
 AakaXa paMGarÜnaI jaga XaaMt JaÜplao ho
 
 
 | 
| | Vshailesh 
 |  |  |  | Saturday, September 04, 2004 - 1:25 pm: |       |  
 | 
 Gharana ya vishayachi khoopach sadhak badhak charcha zaleli disate.
 
 I would like to add that, we should not restrict our discussion to Gayakichi gharani. I have heard that Sangeet is made up of Geet, vadya aani nrutya.
 
 SO can somebody start a thread/ shed some light on Gharani for other two aspect of Sangeet(i.e. Vadya aani Nrutya) as well?
 
 I would like to know your views on this.
 
 If you want to discuss in this regards online, go ahead and add me on MSN/yahoo(shailesh_vartak@hotmail.com shailesh_vartak@yahoo.co.in)
 
 Thanks,
 Shailesh
 
 
 | 
| | Chinmay 
 |  |  |  | Monday, September 06, 2004 - 7:03 am: |       |  
 | 
 tbalaa cao GaraNao
 
 tbalaa cao mau#yat 6 GarNao Aahot
 1. idllaI GarNaa
 2. AjaraDa GarNaa
 3. laKnaÝ GarNaa
 4. banaarsa GarNaa
 5. ÔÉKabaad GarNaa
 6. pMjaaba GarNaa
 
 idllaI GarNaa ha savaa-t jaunaa GarNaa Aaho Asa mhNatat.
 
 tbalaacyaa pirxaa dotanaa ho GaraNao AaNaI %yaaMcao baaja ho idvasa ra~ basauna paz kolao hÜto..pNa Aata
tovZ\yaa  detail maQao Aazvat naahI.
   
 
 
 
 | 
| Gayakanchi kay kimva vadakanchi kay. Gharanich ata kaalabahya hoat chalalee ahet. Aajkal kuthlahi gaayak mhatla ki tyane 2-3 gurunkade shiklela asatoch. mag gharanyanna kay artha rahila?
 
 
 
 | 
| maI saMgaItatIla AÝrMgajaoba Aaho. ivaXaoYata Xaais~ya. pNa malaa Asao vaaTtoya kI [qalaI jaI cacaa- caalalaIya
tI ihndustanaI saMgaItacaIca caalalaIya. knaa-Tk saMgaIt Aqavaa dixaNa BaartIya saMgaItaba_la cacaa- idsat
naahI.... %yaatIla AaiNa ihndustanaI saMgaItatIla raga saarKoca Asatat kaya Æ
 gammat mhNajao kanaDI Aqavaa di@XaNaI gaayakanaI ]<arokDcao Xaais~ya saMgaIt iXaklao pNa maharaYT/atIla
Aqavaa ]<arokDIla laÜkanaI knaa-Tk Aqavaa dixaNaI saMgaItat p`ivaNya imaLivalaolao idsat naahI . Asao
ka Jaalao AsaavaoÆ
 
 
 | 
| | Gautami 
 |  |  |  | Friday, October 15, 2004 - 5:10 pm: |       |  
 | 
 idnaoXaÊ
 
 Aaplyaa  June 12, 2004 - 11:17 am:  yaa  post  maQao mhTlyaap`maaNao tÜ t>a tumhI prt [qao TakU Xakala kaÆ ikMvaa  email  kolaat trI caalaola.  Thanks in advance.
 
 
 | 
| | Dineshvs 
 |  |  |  | Tuesday, October 19, 2004 - 2:14 pm: |       |  
 | 
 KupjaNaanaa tÜ t>a hvaaca hÜta. ha e@saola maQao AahoÊ tsaoca tÜ naIT idsaNyaasaazIÊ iXavaajaI ÔaÐT\sa
Asaayalaa hvaot.
 
 
 | 
| | Dineshvs 
 |  |  |  | Tuesday, October 19, 2004 - 2:30 pm: |       |  
 | 
 maIdoKIla knaa-TkI gaayanapwtIcaa jaaNakar naahI. pNa malaa maaiht Asalaolao Ôrk qao ilaihtÜ.
 
 Aaplao svar ho kuzoih saarKoca Aahot. %yaamauLo Ôrk Aaho tÜ kovaL gaayanapwtIt.
 
 svaraMcaI vaogavaogaLo samauh Gao}na raga tyaar hÜtÜÊ ih mauL pwt tIcaÊ %yaamauLo raga tsaoca Aahot. Kupsao
samaanaih Aahot. Ô> %yaaMcaI naavao vaogavaogaLI Aahot.
 ]da. Aaplaa klaavatI tÜ %yaaMcaa nat-kI. Aaplaa malhar tÜ %yaaMcaa ibalhD vaOgaro.
 
 yaa dÜnhI pQatIt dovaaNaGaovaaNaih hÜt Asatoca. %yaaMcyaa hMsaQvanaIt ³%yaaMcaa ]ccaar hmsaQvaina´ Aaplyaa
XaMkra ragaacaI Jalak Aaho.
 
 latanao ho dÜnhI raga gaayalaot.
 yaa ragaatlaI %yaaMcaI mauL rcanaa
 vaataima gaNaptI
 AXaI Aaho %yaavar latanao
 data tu gaNapit gajaanana
 Asao gaIt gaayalaoya.
 haca raga puvaI- itnaoÊ mannaaDo barÜbar
 
 jaa tÜsao nahI baÜlau knhOyaa
 
 ikMvaa maIrabaacao Bajana
 
 saMtÜ krmaik gat nyaarI
 
 saazI vaaprlaaya.
 
 itcyaa XaMkra ragaatlyaa rcanaa
 
 JanaJanaako ApnaI payala
 calaI maO Aaja mat puCÜ kha
 
 tsaoca
 
 do ho iXavaa maÜho eosaa varÊ
 XauBakr manako saba puNa- kÉ
 
 ih gauÉbaaNaItlaI rcanaa.
 
 Aaplyaa naaT\yagaItat pNa Kup vaoLa knaa-TkI raga vaaprlao Aaho.
 
 Arisak iktI ha XaolaaÊ ikMvaa paMDu naRpit janak jayaaÊ ih dÜnhI pdo mauL knaa-TkI ragaatlaI.
 
 Da^. vasaMtrava doXapaMDonaI gaayalaolao
 
 Gao CMd makrMd
 hohI saalagavaraLI yaa knaa-TkI ragaatlaoca. %yaamauLo eKada raga dÜnhI pwtIt vaogavaogaLa gaata yaotÜca.
 
 Ô> AaplyaakDo jao ragaanaa p`hracao baMQana AahoÊ to knaa-TkI pwtIt naahI.
 maI eoklao naahI pNa maailanaI rajaurkrÊ Da^. p`Baa A~o dÜnhI pwtIcyaa jaaNakar AahotÊ Asao vaacalao hÜto.
 Aapllyaa iktI- iXalaodarnaohIÊ
 XaMkraBarNama ih tolagau rcanaaÊ va ramanaIla maoGaXyaamaaÊ ih kanaDI rcanaaÊ %yaa XaOlaIt AitYaya sauMdrir%yaa
gaayalaIya.
 
 baakI ragaivastaravar jaaNakar p`kaXa TaktIlaca.
 
 
 | 
| knaa-Tk saMgaItatIla talapwtIivaYayaI kÜNaalaa maaihtI Aaho kaÆ
 
 
 | 
| | Shriramb 
 |  |  |  | Wednesday, October 20, 2004 - 8:33 am: |       |  
 | 
 
 prvaaca pM. BaImasaona jaÜXaI AaiNa ema\ baalamaurilaÌYNana yaaMcaI jaugalabaMdI eoklaI. pMiDtjaI yamanaÊ
maalakMsa va BaOrvaI gaayalao.
 yaa ragaaMcao knaa-TkI  equivalent  Aahot kaÆ Asalyaasa kÜNatoÆ kI hoca raga knaa-TkI ZMgaanao gaata yaotatÆ
 
 
 | 
| | Abhijit 
 |  |  |  | Thursday, October 21, 2004 - 2:01 am: |       |  
 | 
 ihMdusqaanaI yamana  =  knaa-TIk klyaaNaI
 ihMdusqaanaI maalakMsa  =  knaa-TIk ihMDÜlama
 ihMdusqaanaI BaOrvaI  =  knaa-TIk BaOrvaI
 
 However, I don't know whether there are any variations in these raagaas in Carnatic about, komal-shudha swaras used and their treatment et al.
 
 
 | 
| | Shriramb 
 |  |  |  | Thursday, October 21, 2004 - 11:57 am: |       |  
 | 
 thanks Abhijit.
 baryach divasani dislaas..
 
 
 
 | 
| | Storvi 
 |  |  |  | Thursday, October 21, 2004 - 3:44 pm: |       |  
 | 
 Sakhee tula nemke kay have ahe?
 mhanje donhi sangeet padhattinmadhye taalahi samantar ahet fakta nava vegvegli astat(ankhi hi thode farak ahet pan nominal).
 
 For eg hindustani rupak, to Carnatic Mishra chapu etc.
 
 pan tula exactly kay mahiti havi ahe te kalale, tar me ankhi thode savistar sangu shaken.
 
 
 
 | 
| Ôarsaa AByaasa nasalyaanao maaJyaa yaa baabatIt  concepts Ôar   clear  naahIt.
 pNa maaJyaa maaihtIp`maaNao knaa-Tk saMgaItat 7 mau#ya tala Aahot  : Qa`uva Ê maz\yaÊ ÉpkÊ JaMpaÊ i~pUTÊ AT AaiNa ek.
 maga yaa p`%yaok talaacaI vaogavaogaLI zravaIk AMga Asatat ³laGauÊ d`utÊ Anaud`ut vaap$na´ AaiNa talaacyaa
maa~a yaa jaaitp`maaNao ³itEaÊ catuEaÊ KMDÊ imaEaÊ saMkINa-´ badlatat.
 
 tU yaa baabatIt kahI   elaborate k$ Xaktosa kaÆ
 
 
 
 
 
 
 |